Now I don't normally do this but...
I have gotten little past half way through this final season of the Shakugan no Shana anime and found that it was so frustrating that I just wanted to pull my hair out at times. Granted the combat scenes were well organized and the general idea of the "ancient war" between Flames Hazes and denizens coming to an end was a good one. I think though instead of having Yuji go "well, I think I will just become the worlds biggest douche bag and change sides on a whim because I don't want Shana fighting and putting her life in harms way anymore" he should've been manipulated or brainwashed or SOMETHING then him just going along with this plot because "ends justify the means" this isn't how Yuji was and definitely not how he should've been.
Back in season one proves my point where he sacrificed his power of existence (prior to finding out about the Midnight Lost Child) to save his classmates after a Crimson Denizen attacked his school shows that he was willing to do the right thing no matter what the cost was to "his personal well being". In season 3 he was willing to do anything no matter what the cost. Period. End of Sentence. And the sudden change in his mind set left me going "wtf?" at the very beginning they showed "something" of him being convinced that this was the right thing to do by the enemy, but it seemed just too simple.
I had heard that season 3 was a disappointment and there were times when I, as I said before, wanted to pull my hair out. Using Shana was a prisoner cliche, but nothing wrong with that, following through with a similar plot at the end of season 1 and using Yuji as a vessel for unlimited power for said Snake of the Festival *cough*Fertilizer*cough* would've worked too.
On a side note, Snake of the Fertilizer is perfect for the amount of shit he spouts about doing whatever he is doing for both Flame Hazes and Denizens then turning around and doing nothing while his denizens attack demoralized Flame Hazes true to point (Sorry for any spoilerage). On another point to that I don't believe that a Flame Hazes mind is so fragile that a simple and idiotic speech from someone leading a group hell bent on "devouring human lives for power" would leave them in such a state.
But, this story is so messed up and convoluted it left me yelling at the tv and my roommate on how stupid and retarded it all was. I know they were "trying" to give the series a memorable finale, but all in all, I think "so far" that season 3 is a disappointment. Don't get me wrong, I will be finishing up season 3 tomorrow.
Now onto various points of work.
Storyline 1/5: IMHO, sucked. It would start to look like it was turning good at one point then turn around and then ramble immediately AFTER it started to look good. The only "few" good points was Sato and Margery relationship coming to a head (literally). The return of previous season characters. Introducing new Flame Hazes with incredible powers. The other good point is Shana actually growing up from the immature, impatient girl to somebody who - more or less - becomes tactically minded and not rushing headlong into battle like she used too in Season 1 and bits of Season 2. That was one of the other things that caused me to fall in love with this series, simply because Flame Hazes tended to be hot-headed and had the tendency to "leap before you look".
One other topic such as the "heroes" having simple minds: It seemed that the "good guys" were all so easily manipulated and goaded that the bad guys just had to voice their reasons and the like to make their enemies fall into a crazed panic. Leaving only a few sound of mind. Which begs the question: "If such omnipotent beings such of Crimson Lords choose these people to help protect the human race, would they NOT choose people of stronger wills and minds?" I am aware that some of these people might've been chosen on the spot, but would not the Crimson Lords consider conditioning the minds of their vessels when they had the chance? Again, that part of the Storyline left me simply shaking my head.
Music 3.5/5: openings and closing, battle scores and such wasn't too bad.
Voice Acting 4.5/5: Because I bought the original series of the when it first came out I loved the original voice actors. They were perfect for the rolls. Don't get me wrong, the new voice actors did well and many well known voice actors were used for the 2nd and 3rd Seasons I bought, but they just didn't seem to have the same kind of strength as the first season did. And I don't even know why, Colleen Clinkenbeard, Todd Haberkorn, Josh Grelle, Cherami Leigh (though she does bring her usual energy to the main character Shana), Kent Williams (to list a few) have always been favorites of mine.
Action 3.5/5: Well, needless to say, action rocked it was an epic war but with the long speeches in between the combat left it wanting.
Art 5/5: Brilliant and beautiful artwork, as it was for the first two seasons.
In short: If you haven't watched the series and want to. Watch Seasons 1 and 2. If you feel compelled to watch Season 3 consider it a... completely different story and following two different characters with the same name. Or watch season 3 separately and mute Snake and Yuji when he/they goes on his/their tangents.
Sorry, like I said, I NORMALLY don't do this, I am a big anime fan and I originally DIDN'T THINK I was this hardcore a fan of this series, but the total turn around and the incredibly BAD story telling of the third season just turned me into a hardcore fan, this was simply too much and left me just angered at how horrible season 3 is.